If you’re looking for a place to grab dessert in the middle keys, look no further than Islamorada. Islamorada community is home to some of Florida’s best dessert and ice cream spots. From handcrafted ice cream sandwiches to key lime pie bars, there’s something for everyone here. Warning: You may be unable to resist their delicious desserts and ice creams (especially all the varieties of key lime pie)!
Is there anything better than a delicious dessert after a nice meal or after a hot walk? Yes, the Keys get HOT despite being surrounded by water. If you’re looking for the best dessert and ice cream shops in Islamorada, you’ve come to the right place. From classic ice creams to decadent cakes, the shops below have something for everyone. So, what are you waiting for? Start indulging!
Best places to grab Ice Cream
Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream
Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream is a local shop in Islamorada that is known for its delicious Key Lime Pie and Key Lime Pie on a stick, Homemade Ice Cream, Artisan Chocolates, and a variety of sweets. The shop’s sophisticated atmosphere makes it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a sweet treat. The key lime pie is by far the most popular item on the menu, but the homemade ice cream and artisan chocolates are also worth trying. Keys Chocolates & Ice Cream is the perfect place to go for a unique and delicious dessert experience.
Location: 100470 Overseas HwyKey Largo, FL 3303
Mr. C’s Homemade Ice Cream
Mr. C’s Homemade Ice Cream is one of the best places to go for ice cream in Islamorada. They have a wide variety of flavors, all homemade and taste delicious. Their bestsellers are the chocolate chip cookie dough and the mint chocolate chip, but they also have other great flavors like strawberry, cookies and cream, and peanut butter cup. What makes Mr. C’s Homemade Ice Cream so special is that they use only the freshest ingredients and make their ice cream from scratch. This results in a product that is truly unique and delicious. If you’re looking for a nice place to get ice cream in Islamorada, check out Mr. C’s Homemade Ice Cream. You won’t be disappointed!
Location: 86701 Overseas Hwy suite 1, Islamorada, FL 33036
Charli’s Shave Ice
Charli’s Shave Ice is a must-visit when you’re in Islamorada! They use only 100% organic local cane sugar to make their delicious shave ice, and they have different flavors to choose from. Their specials are definitely worth trying – the ice cream on the bottom is an amazing touch! Some food items are topped off with a drizzle of sweetened condensed milk. In addition to their delicious shave ice, Charli’s proudly serves locally made Chocolate Covered Key Lime Bars. And if you’re looking for something else sweet to try, they also have a selection of locally made scooped ice cream that changes each month – but it’s always delicious!
Location: 77522 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Best Bakeries and Cafés
Midway Café & Coffee Bar
Midway Café & Coffee Bar is a charming café located in the heart of Islamorada, Florida. The restaurant is renowned for its delicious coffee and espresso, as well as its wide selection of breakfast pastries and lunch items. Midway Café & Coffee Bar is the perfect place to enjoy a quick bite or a leisurely meal while enjoying the beautiful Florida Keys. The café offers a variety of unique items on its menu, including several vegan and vegetarian options, making it a superb choice for all diners. The coffee bar also has an extensive wine list, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a glass of wine with your meal. Midway Café & Coffee Bar is ideal for all your dining needs, whether you are looking for a quick snack or a leisurely dinner.
Location: 80499 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Bob’s Bunz
Bob’s Bunz is a unique restaurant and bakery based in Islamorada, Florida. They serve breakfast daily and are known for their delicious sticky buns. Their sticky buns are made with fresh, local ingredients and are served warm and gooey. They also offer a variety of other baked goods, including muffins, cookies, and cakes. Bob’s Bunz is the perfect place to start your day in the Florida Keys!
Location: 81620 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Key Lime Pie Lady
Key Lime Pie Lady is a local business in the Village of Islamorada, in the Florida Keys. They are most popular for their delicious Key Lime Pie, but they also offer a range of other sweet treats. Their latest offerings include chocolate-dipped key lime pie ice cream bars, bite-size key lime tartlets, and small batch key lime pie ice cream. Key Lime Pie Lady is unique because its products are locally crafted with only the finest ingredients. Their desserts have been featured in numerous magazines and publications and won awards. If you’re ever in the area, stop by and try one of their delectable treats!
Location: 81868 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Café Moka Islamorada
Café Moka Islamorada is a unique cafe located in Islamorada, Florida. They offer a wide-variety of coffee drinks and pastries that are sure to please any coffee lover. Their bestsellers include Café Mocha and Iced Coffee. They also offer a selection of teas and juices. The café is decorated with beautiful Islamic art and has a relaxed and comfortable atmosphere. The staff is welcoming, and they make sure that every customer feels at home. Café Moka Islamorada is the perfect place to enjoy a delicious cup of coffee or tea while relaxing in the beautiful Florida Keys.
Location: 81868 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Bitton Bistro Café
Bitton Bistro Café is a charming French café in the heart of Islamorada. They serve espresso, crepes, gelato, salads, sandwiches, and other desserts here. The café is unique because it is one of the only cafes in the area that serves authentic French cuisine. It is a nice spot to enjoy a delicious meal or snack while watching the world go by. So come and enjoy a taste of France in the Florida Keys!
Location: 82245 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Bayside Gourmet
Bayside Gourmet in Islamorada is a popular spot for locals and tourists alike. They offer a broad variety of pizzas and pasta, desserts, other Italian dishes, and craft brews. The café has a modern vibe and a patio area for dining. Bayside Gourmet is known for its delicious food and friendly staff. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack or a sit-down meal, Bayside Gourmet is the place grab dessert in the middle keys.
Location: 82758 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Sink your teeth into something sweet at the best place to grab dessert in Islamorada and the middle keys. From old-fashioned ice cream parlors to trendy cafes, this island has something for everyone to grab dessert in the middle keys. If you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind experience, head to The Key Lime Pie Lady and try their namesake dish. Or, if you want to enjoy a classic treat, stop by the Keys Chocolate and Ice Cream. No matter your preference, we are sure you will be satisfied with the best place to grab dessert in Islamorada.
